Harry does it again. The Redbreast Book Review


It is 1942: a Norwegian soldiers fighting on the Eastern front, on the German side, is killed. One of his comrades, injured in the same incident, falls in love with a Austrian nurse whilst recuperating.

57 years later, a Detective in Oslo with the unlikely name of Harry Hole is appointed to the Norwegian secret service, his brief is to monitor Neo-Nazi activity in Norway: a fairly mundane assignment that turns out to be anything but….

Norway Akerhus
Akershus fortress in Oslo where scenes in the book are set


With many parallels to recent world events and rising anti-multicultural sentiment, Nesbø’s, ‘The Redbreast‘, (which won the Glass Key, the Riverton and the Norwegian Book club Prize for the best ever Norwegian Crime Novel),  will take the reader both on a historic and also a contemporary journey.

Chillingly ironic and yet at times, familiar were some of the attitudes found amongst the more despicable characters in the book. It digs deep into the hearts and minds of those Norwegians who felt passionate enough to risk their lives, fighting alongside and for the Nazis, during the war. They believed in saving Norway from, what they saw, was the Bolshevik advance.

The Novel delves into their individual motives and how they might have felt on their return to Norway, when they discovered they had been labelled ‘traitors,’  shunned by their own society after war’s end; a topic rarely written about in the Western world.




A different perspective can reveal things hitherto unseen, and at times, I was surprised I that Ifelt a little sympathy for these men, despite philosophically being poles apart from them.  It made me question the modern politic climate of Norway. The massacre on Utøya, Norway and now the terrorist attack on the mosque in Christchurch, New Zealand, which appears to have links to Utøya, made me wonder  if there might be some more citizens with these beliefs, hidden surreptitiously, under a guise of normality. Let’s hope not.


Oslo fjord
Oslo fjord

The Good: Following a hunch that several murders are linked, Harry pays a high personal price in the book, but still manages to find a little romance in all the horror. I found this an unlikely but interesting diversion, but it provides Hole with a clue vital in solving the mystery.

The Bad: Although we know the killer’s mind from the start (but not who he is), he remains carefully hidden through out the book, his actions being explained by a slightly unbelievable trip to a psychiatrist.

The Ugly: One wonders how many readers might feel sympathy for these “traitors” or even perversely idolize them as historic “warriors,” using this as justification for the Neo Nazi  “thuggish” behaviour. I am not sure.  Yet there is still the theme of redemption offered up to readers too, albeit in small amounts.

This was the first of the Harry Hole series to be translated into English, and since then, every book in the series has been translated and was a best seller.

Recommended for those who like Nordic Noir/Scandi Detective fiction and have not yet read Harry Hole.

StPA’s Rating: 7/10




9 thoughts on “Harry does it again. The Redbreast Book Review”

  1. Sounds like an interesting read, Amanda, but not one I’ll rush to buy. There’s more than enough violence in this world for me. I was just lately reading a well written Sebastian Faulks Holocaust story. It’s not good to know that the evil is still out there.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I can understand that, Jo. Some things we have to read, and some we don’t. Thank goodness this is fictional. I don’t actually enjoy true crime for the reasons that you outlined.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Really? After reading your post, I am a bit surprised. I guess when you live it for so long each year, it loses its appeal. But there is this dramatic stark raw beauty in the bare trees, the snow littering the ground and that low ethereal light – could you call it crepuscular?? I have been to Oslo in both summer and winter, and winter definitely is preferable for me.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. That is so true. Living there for a long time makes me tired and sleepy in that darkness and grayness. But after a break from it everything seems charming. Because now it has become a part of me too))
        Uii, such an unusual choice! Most people love Norwegian summer. Bc it is the best days of the year 😆

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Sounds like a good read. I’m not surprised you felt a bit of sympathy for the villains in the story. Even villains have their story and reasons for their ideals, no matter how warped and twisted we find their ideals to be. I believe it’s only by of trying to understand how people have developed a belief system that we have any hope of modifying any fundamental behaviours attached to those belief systems.

    Liked by 1 person

Everyone is important. What do you have to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.